Sam makes her first appearance in the apartment she and Tyler live in together, where it's revealed a frequent dispute between the couple is Sam's dislike of Tyler's job as a police officer. The risks associated with the job causes her worry and anxiety, and she suggests moving to Florida where they can work with her parents, to which Tyler will reject.
Sam is last seen near the end of the game, where she arrives at the police station to give Tyler an ultimatum, for him to stay in New York or leave with her to Florida. The choice is up to the player.
- Sam appears in the Bonus feature "Sam's Dance."
- The voice actor for Sam, Sharon Mann, also voices Markus Kane as a child.